• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home Page
  • About this website and the writer
  • Testimonials
  • Archives
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Contact Page

Defrosting Cold Cases

Unsolved cases that need your attention

  • Cold Case Database
    • Index
      • Cases Index A-G
      • Cases Index H-N
      • Cases Index O-Z
    • Summaries
      • Case Summaries A-G
      • Case Summaries H-N
      • Case Summaries O-Z
  • Two Research Methods
  • Search Tips
  • Case of the Month
  • Guest Writers
  • Book Reviews
You are here: Home / Book Reviews / The Good Ones by Polly Stewart

The Good Ones by Polly Stewart

August 25, 2023 By Alice

If this is Polly Stewart’s debut crime novel, get ready for more splendid books in the future because as a writer, this book is extremely well written.

The exploration of Virginia’s landscape, the towns, the community, the people, and the insight Stewart gives into their relationships, bring this book alive.

On the cover, the book is described as a thriller, a mystery. It is not a thriller and only hints at a mystery.

The two major plotlines concern high school friends Nicola Bennett and Lauren Ballard. Ballard, the popular one, Bennett, the loyal companion. Stewart takes us through their years together up to the point where Ballard goes missing. She leaves behind a husband and a very young daughter.

The day before she went missing, Ballard damaged a car as punishment for parking too close to her. It is not clear whether Ballard was perfectly parked herself  to begin with or that the driver parked so close on purpose. Yet, she vandalizes the car. Is that the catalyst for her disappearance? No, it is too simple.

The car is described as a new Chevy Silverado so if bought from a dealer, vandalism is covered in your comprehensive car policy. In other words, not a reason to kidnap a person and make them disappear. It immediately, at least for me, shifted the tone of the crime novel indicating that whatever happened to Ballard is grounded in the past.

Bennett, who after graduation tried to get her career going, ends up back in her old town in Tyndall County. This plotline follows all the thoughts Bennett once had as a teen, believed them to be true, only to discover twenty years later that there’s another side to the story. She wishes to catch up with people, but they have moved on. She wishes to be unnoticed by some as being back in town feels like a failure. She wishes to make amends but is stunned that people do not forgive and console her.

Bennett returned home to prepare and ultimately sell her mother’s house as she passed away. However, the reader gets the feeling that secretly Bennett is fixing the house with the option to live there herself. There is no other home, no other place where she set up roots. She accepts a job in the county’s public school system as you feel she needs to be back in that old high school because psychologically, she has not made peace with the past. She never moved on. She never understood her feelings for people then and still does not understand them when she sees people after twenty years as an adult. She doesn’t understand herself.

Old actions on Bennett’s part, that had lasting effects on others, now present themselves as revelations hinting at her immaturity. That same immature causes her to make bad decisions in the present while she tries to find out what happened to Ballard. Ballard’s remains were never found. Did she go missing or did she disappear of her own free will? Who would do this to her and in case she faked her crime, why?

We meet several characters in the book. Lovers, husbands, their brother, and his friends. Their stories are wonderfully described, and it is a joy to read. Stewart took her time developing their lines.

The book’s ending though feels as if it was quickly written down after the idea came up. However, unlike the rest of the book, it never benefitted from the time Stewart dedicated to polishing the prose and finding the right words. Is the ending possible? Doubtful as it required a lot of planning that somehow does not seem to match the character. It is for you to find out who I am talking about. When you do, ask yourself why they turned out like this. I am not convinced that becomes clear in the book.

The pace of the book is not what you’d expect from a thriller. There are a few mysterious elements but they do not dominate the plot. I guess that Stewart’s book is at its best when it forces the reader to think about the characters’ actions and reflect upon their own lives. What would I have done? We all have dark and light in us. We can all be tempted, but where do you draw the line? Would I have interfered, would I have asked for help, would I be able to turn in someone I know? Would I be able to swallow my pride and tell the truth? And most importantly, why do I feel stuck and in need of these answers before I can move on?

Stewart’s book is a joy to read even if it isn’t what I thought it was going to be. I will not hesitate to pick up her next one. My other book reviews are here.

Thank you for sharing!

  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to share on Mastodon (Opens in new window) Mastodon
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • More
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window) Pocket
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
  • Click to share on Nextdoor (Opens in new window) Nextdoor

Related

Filed Under: Book Reviews Tagged With: Book Reviews, Polly Stewart

Primary Sidebar

Dina Fort

Top Posts & Pages

  • Cold Case Database
  • Archive
  • Justice for Antonella Mattina
  • Case of the Month: Hinterkaifeck
  • Who killed Beth Ann Brown Patterson?

Categories

  • Book Reviews (182)
  • Case of the Month (130)
  • Cold Case News (226)
  • Forensics (287)
  • Guest Bloggers (57)
  • Miscarriages of Justice (131)
  • Missing Persons (126)
  • Unidentified (32)
  • Unsolved (524)
  • Zeigler (65)

Author Notes

Since 2009, I write about unsolved cases that need renewed media attention. I only do research and leave active investigations to the authorities.

My posts cover homicides, missing and unidentified people, wrongful convictions, and forensics as related to unsolved cases.

On book reviews: I only review select works of true crime, crime fiction, and historical fiction/mysteries. The stories have to fit my website's theme, tone, and research. It is my prerogative to not review a book. Please check the FAQ page for more.

My databases are free to the public. Cases are sorted by the victim’s last name.

If you have any questions about my website please check the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) page, the About page, and the tabs in both menu bars. If you cannot find the answers there, please contact me.

Thank you,

Alice de Sturler
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

Subscribe to DCC by email

Enter your email address to get new posts notifications in your inbox

Copyright

If you use my work, please add a link back. Let your readers know where you found your information. I do the same for you. Thank you!

Protected by Copyscape

Copyright © 2025 ·News Pro · Genesis Framework by StudioPress · WordPress