• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About the author and her website
  • References
  • Archives
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Contact Page

Defrosting Cold Cases

Research website by Alice de Sturler

  • My Research Method
  • How to search for cases
  • Cold Case Database
    • Index
      • Cases Index A-G
      • Cases Index H-N
      • Cases Index O-Z
    • Summaries
      • Case Summaries A-G
      • Case Summaries H-N
      • Case Summaries O-Z
  • Case of the Month: Lakota Renville
  • Book Reviews
You are here: Home / Book Reviews / Mycroft & Sherlock by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Anna Waterhouse

Mycroft & Sherlock by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Anna Waterhouse

April 22, 2020 By Alice

Mycroft & Sherlock by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Anna WaterhouseMycroft & Sherlock The Empty Birdcage by Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Anna Waterhouse is the third book in a series. I have not read the previous two books. Therefore, my review should be seen as a stand-alone and not as a review of the entire series.

Two story lines and two sets of detectives

The Empty Birdcage starts in London, England. The year is 1873. On April 1, Mycroft Holmes is prepared for surgery. He is twenty-seven years old and worries what will become of his reputation if the public knows that he had heart surgery. However, his condition is rapidly deteriorating. He thinks about his younger brother Sherlock and before the morphine kicks in, he asks the surgeon if he cleaned his hands and elbows as per his instructions.

One month later, we meet Sherlock who is suffering at Cambridge as he’d rather be investigating the eight serial murders that have Great Britain holding its breath. The victims vary in age, gender, profession, and social and financial status. But, they do have things in common. There do not seem to be any obvious traces of violence or trauma. At first glace they could have died of natural causes. And, they all have a note: The Fire Four Eleven!

After Mycroft is recovered, he finds himself investigating a kidnapping. Deshi Hai Lin, the father of Ai Lin, asks Mycroft to help find his daughter’s fiance, Bingwen Shi. Ai Lin is apparently the love who either got away or Mycroft never expressed his feelings for her. As I did not read the previous two books, I do not know if she plays a role in those books. Here, she is the one he wishes to spend the rest of his life with and to be asked to find her fiance, is painful. But he accepts.

Two storylines unfold, the hunt for the kidnapped fiance and the serial killer. We see two sets of detectives investigating. Mycroft is assisted, protected, and accompanied by his best friend Cyrus Douglas. Sherlock is offended to be accompanied by Mycroft’s carriage driver Huan, but quickly learns that Huan is a master observer who has skills that save him.

The book

As the book has been out since September 2019, there are many reviews online about the plot. So I am only adding my opinion here.

It is nice to see a more human side of Mycroft. What he feels and thinks, how he tries to keeps his emotions at bay, and reluctantly but dutifully takes care of his younger brother. His need for privacy, order, the luxury and sanctuary of his own home, it makes him a well-rounded character. Maybe even more so than the Mycroft in the books by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Sherlock is his impatient all-over-the-place self who sets aside everything to focus on a case. His deductive skills are sharp and he learns to appreciate Huan.

I like the part near the end where Mycroft explains his case to Edward Cardwell in the War Office. It gives a good overview of the case, the weighing of national and personal interests, and the acceptance of consequences. However, the letter at the end of the book feels forced, like a prelude to a fourth book.

Critique

Minor critique: the way that Cyrus escapes when he is captured reminds me of a Cirque du Soleil act. This part in the story doesn’t match the overal tone of the book which is devoid of graphic descriptions. But that isn’t my major point of critique.

Both story-lines end in a disappointing manner. Mycroft’s ending of the case was good until the letter at the end of the book. It takes away the logic and feels unnecessary. The ending of Sherlock’s case is even worse. It is his case where Mycroft and Sherlock finally put their brain powers together. And how it ends, is very disappointing. Let me explain why.

The book opens with a killer stalking, watching his next victim. Then, we learn that there already were eight murders in Great Britain. However, throughout the book we learn little about the killer, their motives, their preparations, and how they arranged their logistics.

We only see parts of this through the deductions that Sherlock makes in his investigations. However, when it becomes clear that the motive is revenge, we learn nothing about the victim who is avenged. Nothing, not even a name.

There is this huge build-up of finally confronting a serial killer who must be stopped. And when they find him, it is over in less than two pages.

This serial killer has obviously researched their killing method. We do not learn why they selected this convoluted method over other methods. We never get inside the killer’s brain. We never see a train of thought, a breakdown of emotions, a regrouping to fortify themselves to carry on, or even a reflection about the beloved victim. 

While the authors did a great job exploring the characters of Mycroft & Sherlock, they do not deliver in the ending of the plots. The books feels anticlimactic.

My other book reviews are here.

Thank you for sharing!

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window)
  • More
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Book Reviews Tagged With: Book Reviews, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Anna Waterhouse

Primary Sidebar

Dina Fort

Author Notes

On this website, I write about old, unsolved cases. Most are from the pre-DNA era and are in need of renewed media attention. I only do research and leave the active investigation of these cases to the professionals.

My posts are about homicides, missing and unidentified people, wrongful convictions, and forensics as related to these cases.

On book reviews: I only review select works of true crime, crime fiction, and historical fiction/mysteries. The stories have to fit my website's theme and research. It remains my prerogative to not review a book.

My database has over 325 cases listed by the victim’s last name. You will find a brief description there as well. The database will always be free to the public to use. You cannot buy ad space on my website, ever.

All writing suggestions that come in by email are added to my to-do list in the order in which they were received. Please be patient. My to-do list is very long but no case gets dropped and I will get back in touch.

Defrosting Cold Cases is NOT an organization. It is my brainchild.

If you have any questions about my website please check the Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) page, the about page, and the tabs in both menu bars. If you still cannot find the answer there, please contact me.

Thank you,

Alice de Sturler

Copyright

If you use my work, please add a link back. Let your readers know where you found your information. I do the same for you. Thank you!

Protected by Copyscape

Categories

Top Posts & Pages

  • Cold Case Database
  • Gina Renee Hall partial remains found
  • How to search for cases
  • What happened to Woodrow Rae Harr?
  • Case of the Month: Hinterkaifeck

Subscribe to DCC by email

Enter your email address to get new posts notifications in your inbox

RSS Defrosting Cold Cases

  • Neosho Grace Doe is Shawna Beth Garber
  • Serial Killers by Joni Johnston, Psy.D.
  • Fatal Intent by Tammy Euliano
  • Lakota Rae Renville (1983 – 2005)
  • Helen Ruth Conwright Young (1936–1976)

William Thomas Zeigler

Category: ALL POSTS

On March 31, 2016, an evidentiary hearing was held to request touch DNA testing. On July 18, 2016, Judge Whitehead denied that request.

On November 23, 2016, an appeal was filed with the Florida Supreme Court. On April 21, 2017, the Florida Supreme Court denied the request for touch DNA analysis.

On May 8, 2017 a motion for a rehearing with the US Supreme Court was filed. It was denied November 13, 2017.

In the summer of 2019, the appeal for DNA testing to the Florida Conviction Integrity Unit was denied.

Richard Lapointe

Category: ALL POSTS

In March 2015, the Connecticut State Supreme Court ordered a new trial for Richard lapointe. On Oct 2, 2015, International Wrongful Conviction Day, Richard was set free. The judge ruled that he cannot be retried for the 1987 rape-murder of Mrs. Bernice Martin. Richard Lapointe died on Aug 4, 2020 of Covid19 complications.

In 1987, someone killed Bernice Martin. I hope that she will not become a forgotten file.
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Copyright: Please add a link back if you use my work. Let your readers know where you found your information. I do the same for you. If you need help with this, just contact me. Thank you, Alice de Sturler

[footer_backtotop]

Copyright © 2009–2021 - Defrosting Cold Cases - All rights reserved · Hosting & WordPress: 3J WordPress Write Data

wordpress counter

loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.